Legal immigration of Indians to the US – It is the taxes stupid!
- In Current Affairs
- 12:20 PM, Mar 12, 2021
- Basker Mathrubootham
Legal immigration of Indians to the US is the most ignored facet of today’s immigration debate. Be it Trump’s border wall or Biden’s DACA proposal no one is willing to talk about the elephant in the room “Legal immigration of Indians”. I had written article about it in 2019. https://www.myind.net/Home/viewArticle/legal-immigration-woes-of-indians-in-the-us Unfortunately, the issue persists even now. It must end and end now.
Consider the following facts.
- CEOs of Alphabet, Microsoft, Adobe, former CEOs of PepsiCo, United airlines, US airways are Indian origin.
- Many Silicon Valley startups employing millions of Americans, professors/researchers in top Ivy league colleges and many universities are also of Indian origin.
- Three of the science and one economics Nobel laureate from the US are from India. For every top achiever mentioned, there are even more achievers of Indian origin making it big in their own inconspicuous way. All these people have one common path to their success story. Finish their early academics in India, come to the US for higher studies, get a job according to their skill levels/competencies at American companies, colleges and eventually become top achieving Americans. Many including Kalpana Chawla who died in the Columbia space shuttle crash in 2002 and VP Kamala Harris’ late mother Dr. Shyamala Gopalan also took the same path.
Also consider these facts-
- A former Connecticut based Indian family (now in Atlanta) took 12 years to get their permanent residence. They are currently US citizens.
- Another friend of mine based out of Harrisburg, PA took 12 years to get her Green card and is now a US citizen.
- A friend of mine who graduated from a top management institution is waiting for the last 9 years to get his green card living in NJ.
- Another has been waiting 11 years to get his green card.
- The list is endless and the waiting list of Indians in the green card line is now more than 600,000.
Short story “Legal immigration for aspiring and hardworking Indians to the US is a nightmare now.”
They packed their bags, came to the US, worked hard to achieve the American dream, bought homes, paid their taxes like good citizens, and raised their families. Despite being the most peace loving (least gun ownership and lowest crime rate among any ethnic community in the US), most prosperous immigrant community and the most diverse community of all (Indians follow 8 faiths and speak 15 languages), the same Indians are getting a raw deal in legal immigration. Worse still not many are even aware of the gravity of this problem. Many in the mainstream discourse speak about the undocumented immigrants but almost never about the legal immigrants in waiting from India.
At the core of it is the archaic concept of 140,000 employment based green cards per year and within that a 7% country specific quota for green card issuance and inclusion of spouse and non-US citizen children under 21 in the quota. Based on the rules, Indians can get no more than 9800 employment based green cards per year. The 140,000 quota was established in the early 90s and clearly needs to be amended. For a country that gets 50% of the 85000 H1B visas and a significant number of the unlimited research/academic H1Bs, it is impossible for one from India to get permanent residence while alive in the US if they apply now for one. Becoming eligible for one will require them to work for the same employer until their I485 is processed. Despite such a glaring anomaly Indians keep their faith in the US and keep pursuing their American dream.
Consider the facts-
- Indian students’ number about 186000 per year and pay international student rates of an average $30,000 per year.
- This alone stands at $5.6 billion per year.
- The same universities subsidize local students so that they can pay in-state fees (free in some states).
- The same students upon getting a job will end up buying a house, pay car loans, pay property taxes, state income taxes, and make many more tangible and intangible contributions to the economy. Taxes in a big state like California with a lot of Indians is as high as 16%, it is indeed remarkably high in states like New York, New Jersey, Illinois, and Pennsylvania.
- A moderately priced home in a non-traditional IT hub like Harrisburg, PA rakes in average of $10K in property taxes, a similar home in Chicago, IL gets $20K, about $6K in Atlanta, GA and about $12K in Austin, TX.
Despite such significant contributions to the economy, Indians’ immigration problem does not get the same attention that Latinos’ get. Senators Chuck Grassley (Iowa), Jeff Sessions (former AL senator), John Kennedy (LA), Rick Scott (FL) have been consistently disdainful towards Indians’ immigration. Senators Dick Durbin (IL) and Rand Paul (KY) wanted expansion of the quota in such a way that it does not affect other countries’ immigrants. Many senators across both parties like Lindsey Graham and Elizabeth Warren have also overwhelmingly supported Indian immigrants as well. Senator Mitt Romney (UT) as Presidential candidate in 2012 supported stapling green cards with university degrees. That did earn my vote for him in 2012. President Trump as candidate while praising Indians’ contribution to the US economy earned some Indian votes for the GOP. But his contribution to the immigration solution was limited to pious platitudes and nothing more. It was just tall talk without any ground level action. All thanks to Stephen Miller, a John Tanton protégé. He and his random policies made lives of Indian immigrants very miserable.
Many of my friends who are affected by this problem are considering relocating to places like Australia, Canada or elsewhere. One of them has already become an Australian citizen. Many have returned to India. After all nobody wants to spend the productive time of their lives worrying about their immigration issues and stay enslaved to a single employer. This legalized slavery is unacceptable. Legal immigration brings freedom. Countries like Australia and Canada are advertising their immigration services and rolling the red carpet for educated immigrants. Losing such immigrants to other countries has consequences. The pandemic has made the work location irrelevant. In some specific cases I have heard about people have gone back to India earning American salaries and paying tax in India. A few others have died based on the social media chatter and their family members are on the verge of being deported to India. The only other affected citizens are of Chinese origin and China has played smart by inviting the US educated graduates to start business in China and setup thriving tech ecosystem in places like Shenzhen, Shanghai etc.
Democrats love high taxes with more government and republicans love big business with less government. But when it comes to rubber meeting the road, democrats support the undocumented immigrants more than the high tax paying ones like Indian tech workers. Coming to republicans, they want jobs to be created by big business in the US but will not support the job creators who hire highly paid legal immigrants and make the cost of doing business exceedingly high. Social media chatter reveals that the legislators are afraid there might be too many Asian origin US citizens migrating. If that be the case are not the Asians also paying high taxes? So, the parties want high taxes but not the people who pay them? Totally unfair and unacceptable.
Genuine attempt to fix the problem was made by a democratic senate in 2013. It ultimately failed in the republican controlled house. Currently there is a genuine push by President Biden to solve the problem and thankfully he is not tying it to legalization of undocumented immigrants. I hope and pray it succeeds.
After all America is “A land of immigrants”? Paraphrasing President Clinton “Ultimately it is the taxes stupid”.

Comments